Skip to content
    Reddit Roundup

    5 Reddit AITA Posts Where 14,000 Strangers Agreed — Without a Single Dissent

    Reddit doesn’t agree on anything. So when a thread hits zero defenders, you stop scrolling and start reading.

    Part of: Reddit Roundups

    By The Daily Stash Editors · Editorial teamLast verified May 4, 20266 min read
    5 Reddit AITA Posts Where 14,000 Strangers Agreed — Without a Single Dissent — Reddit Roundup feature on The Daily Stash

    Reddit famously can’t agree on pizza toppings. So when a thread hits 14,000 comments and every single one says NTA, the post is doing something genuinely rare. These are the five from this month.

    The post that broke the internal record this month came from an Ottawa woman whose mother-in-law tried to rename her newborn three days after the birth. The agreement was unanimous. Even the lurkers came out for it.

    A Winnipeg dad asked if he was wrong for refusing to “share” his retirement savings with his adult son’s failing crypto venture. 14,000 comments, zero defenders.

    Then came the wedding-cake incident. A bride’s sister-in-law brought her own cake. To the reception. Without telling anyone. The verdict was so strong it spawned a follow-up thread.

    Related read: The low-deposit Canadian casino quietly winning over budget players. Sponsored

    A Montreal renter asked if she was wrong for reporting her landlord after he entered her apartment to “check the smell of her candles.” The replies were less about the law and more about the candles.

    The fifth one is short: a teenager in Saskatoon asked if he was wrong for refusing to give up his bedroom for his stepbrother’s podcast studio. Reddit responded with the kind of warmth it usually reserves for golden retrievers.

    Elsewhere on The Daily Stash

    Sources

    1. Reuters technology coverage
    2. BBC Technology
    3. The Guardian technology

    Original editorial. Written by The Daily Stash Editors. See our editorial policy.